AudiologyOnline Phone: 800-753-2160


Earlens - Provider - August 2022

REM: Pure Tones v Speech-Like Signals

Steve Huart, AuD

March 30, 2009

Share:

Question

For a long time we have used pure tone sweeps for real ear measurements, but now the signal of choice is speech, or modulated speech-like noise. Theoretically the use of a pure tone sweep could result in softer aspects of speech to be missed if we use this signal to generate a fitting target. Please can you tell me how big of a deal it is if you use a pure tone versus modulated speech signal? Is it absolutely wrong or could it be "good enough"? Also, from a functional perspective, do we have any evidence to suggest that hearing aid outcomes are different just due to using these different stimulus types?

Answer

First you should be congratulated for using real ear measurements. You are definitely in the minority. In spite of all the evidence that supports probe microphone verification, audiologists and dispensers have not embraced the only truly objective way to verify what a hearing aid does in the ear canal. To answer your first question, it is a great big deal! The frequency, intensity, duration and modulation characteristics of speech have very little in common with pure tone sweeps. Modern nonlinear digital hearing aids will not respond to different signals in the same way. To illustrate, see the figure below. Using two speech like signals (ANSI S3.42 vs. ICRA), you can see that there is at least a 10dB difference in output at all frequencies above approximately 1.5 KHZ. If two speech like signals result in such different curves, you should expect that curves comparing speech and pure tones would be even more divergent. So, using pure tones instead of speech or speech like signals to verify nonlinear digital hearing aids is not good enough.


(Figure reproduced with kind permission of Sallie Frye, Frye Electronics)

Your second question is not easy to answer directly. I am not aware of any published data that suggest people are more satisfied when their hearing aid fitting is verified with probe microphone measures. Dillon (2006, 2003, 1999) has reported that patients do better when the fitting approximates the target and that some prescriptions result in higher speech recognition than others. If 'doing better' means improved speech recognition then the answer to your second question is also yes. Using speech or a speech-like signal will result in a better approximation of the prescribed target and should therefore result in better outcomes.

Anecdotally, Mayo Clinic Arizona is the winter destination for people from all over the world. Working there provided the opportunity to see many winter visitors who had been fit with hearing aids elsewhere and who came to the clinic for a second opinion. Since probe microphone measures were standard practice at Mayo, we often found that people were wearing hearing aids that were frankly not fit well. A simple adjustment in frequency/gain response based on probe microphone findings often resulted in a delighted user who very often asked, "Why didn't they just do that on me when they fit the hearing aid?" That is a great question! Please continue to use probe microphone verification and encourage your colleagues to do so as well. Keep up the good work and good luck.

Suggested readings:

https://frye.com/manuals/7000.pdf

https://www.audiology.org/resources/documentlibrary/Documents/haguidelines.pdf

Dillon, H. (1999). NAL-NL1: A new procedure for fitting non-linear hearing aids. Hearing Journal, 52(4), 10-16.

Dillon, H. (2006). What's new from NAL in hearing aid prescriptions? Hearing Journal,50(10),10-16.

Dillon, H, Keidser, G. (2006). Is probe-mic measurement of HA gain-frequency response best practice? Hearing Journal, 56(4), 28-30.

Dr. Steve Huart has over 20 years experience fitting hearing aids and is an outspoken advocate for objective verification of hearing aid fittings using probe microphone measures. He was a clinical and dispensing audiologist at Mayo Clinic in Arizona before joining Cochlear Americas in 2007. He can be reached at shuart@cochlear.com.


steve huart

Steve Huart, AuD

help dispensing professionals identify and refer those patients who no longer benefit from amplification

Steven A. Huart, Au.D., has over 20 years experience in audiology and hearing aid dispensing. Most of his career has been spent in the clinic seeing patients and fitting hearing aids. Huart was an Instructor in Audiology at Mayo Clinic Arizona and Adjunct Faculty at Arizona School of Health Sciences until he became the Director of Professional Development for AmplifonUSA. He joined Cochlear Americas in 2007 where his goal is to help dispensing professionals identify and refer those patients who no longer benefit from amplification.


Related Courses

A Deeper Look at Sound Environments
Presented by Don Schum, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Oticon

Presenter

Don Schum, PhD
Course: #33536Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Very well articulated'   Read Reviews
The characteristics of the sound environment have a fundamental impact on the performance of the hearing aid user. In this course, we will describe the obvious and sometimes more subtle aspects of sound environments that will affect hearing aid performance.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

The Subjective Evaluation of a New Hearing Aid Fitting
Presented by Don Schum, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Oticon

Presenter

Don Schum, PhD
Course: #35584Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Very informative and pragmatic presentation regarding the importance of incorporating a subjective evaluation into the hearing aid fitting process'   Read Reviews
The final judge of the success of a new fitting will of course be the patient, and the criteria that they use may not always be in line with an objective audiological measure. This course will review some of the issues and options at play when having the patient weigh in on the value of the new devices.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Auditory Wellness: What Clinicians Need to Know
Presented by Brian Taylor, AuD, Barbara Weinstein, PhD
Audio
Signia

Presenters

Brian Taylor, AuDBarbara Weinstein, PhD
Course: #36608Level: Intermediate0.5 Hours
  'i loved the podcast format'   Read Reviews
As most hearing care professionals know, the functional capabilities of individuals with hearing loss are defined by more than the audiogram. Many of these functional capabilities fall under the rubric, auditory wellness. This podcast will be a discussion between Brian Taylor of Signia and his guest, Barbara Weinstein, professor of audiology at City University of New York. They will outline the concept of auditory wellness, how it can be measured clinically and how properly fitted hearing aids have the potential to improve auditory wellness.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Vanderbilt Audiology Journal Club: Clinical Insights from Recent Hearing Aid Research
Presented by Todd Ricketts, PhD, Erin Margaret Picou, AuD, PhD, H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenters

Todd Ricketts, PhDErin Margaret Picou, AuD, PhDH. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Course: #37376Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Interesting points regarding satisfaction and success with hearing aids'   Read Reviews
This course will review new key journal articles on hearing aid technology and provide clinical implications for practicing audiologists.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

61% Better Hearing in Noise: The Roger Portfolio
Presented by Steve Hallenbeck
Recorded Webinar
Mon, May 20, 2024 at 12:00 pm EDT
Phonak

Presenter

Steve Hallenbeck
Course: #38656Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'Clear and concise'   Read Reviews
Every patient wants to hear better in noise, whether it be celebrating over dinner with a group of friends or on a date with your significant other. Roger technology provides a significant improvement over normal-hearing ears, hearing aids, and cochlear implants to deliver excellent speech understanding.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $129/yr

Learn More

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.