iAudiologyOnline – Call us: 800-753-2160
Signia - Styletto AX - September 2022

Is Speech-in-Noise Testing Worth the Effort?

H. Gustav Mueller, PhD

October 10, 2016

Share:

Question

I fit a lot of hearing aids in my practice and am always looking for ways to improve my game.  Is adding speech-in-noise testing worth the effort, and if so, what will I gain from adding it to my clinical protocol?

Answer

Yes, speech-in-noise testing is most definitely worth the effort and rather than give you just one answer, I'll give you six.

Reason #1: To Address the Patient’s Complaints

If someone walks into an optometrist’s office with the complaint of trouble seeing at a distance, the optometrist would have the person read the Snellen eye chart at a distance of twenty feet. Makes sense, right? What if the patient’s main problem was reading magazines and newspapers? If you’re over the age of 40, you may be starting to have trouble reading from that distance and know exactly what I mean.   In this case, the optometrist would have the patient read off a card with different sizes of print at arm's length.  This also makes sense.  What if the complaint were having trouble differentiating colors?   The optometrist would then conduct a standardized test of color differentiation. There are ten different cards that they use for this standardized test.  It’s all pretty clear—they do a test related to the complaint.

Now, let's take the typical patient who comes in to an audiologist's office with the complaint of having trouble understanding speech in background noise. If the person is a potential new hearing aid user, that will likely be the complaint in 90% or more of the cases. What does the average audiologist do? Well, most will assess speech understanding in quiet. Isn’t it a bit strange that people walk in with one problem and we do a test for something totally different?

As in the optometrist example, speech-in-noise testing is a way to show the patient that, yes, I understand your problem and, therefore, I'm going to do a test related to why you came to see me in the first place. It helps to foster the professional-patient relationship; it shows that you are listening and you understand their reason for the visit.

Reason #2: Results from Speech-in-Noise Testing Will Help you Select the Best Technology

A common speech-in-noise test is the QuickSIN.  When the QuickSIN was first introduced, Mead Killion suggested that it might help determine who really needs directional technology and who doesn't. Today, most everyone is fitted with directional technology, and even basic instruments usually have this feature, so this logic doesn’t really apply anymore. The test results however, will help you to address some other special needs, such as the need for remote microphones. It also may help you make decisions for a unilateral versus a bilateral fitting, or what ear to fit when the patient only wants to purchase one hearing aid. Perhaps, it may even help you decide when to fit a BiCROS if you see that the score is so bad in one ear that the patient may not obtain much benefit if that ear were aided. 

Reason #3: To Establish a Baseline for Measuring Aided Benefit 

By doing a baseline speech in noise measure, you can later determine the benefits of hearing aids, and demonstrate to the patient that hearing aids indeed work in background noise.  Without the baseline measure, you have no reference for aided outcome on the day of the fitting.

Reason #4: To Monitor Performance Over Time, Such as Year Over Year

When you've conducted a very reliable, controlled test you can then monitor changes over time. Research has shown that there is very little correlation between speech in quiet results and performance on a speech in noise test. If you monitor a person over time by using their speech recognition in quiet, you may not identify that their speech recognition in noise performance is going down. Your clinical findings will now be more likely to be in synch with the patient history.

Reason #5: To Assist with Counseling

Now, you have a test that can help you discuss with the patient how they might do in various situations. It will very easily explain why they're having trouble in certain listening situations and you have that information in front of you (you know what SNRs will give them problems). If you do aided testing, which is yet another use of these tests, you now will be able to give them realistic expectations for different types of real-world listening situations.

Reason #6: To Help Patients Make a Decision

Speech-in-noise testing can help patients who are not sure whether or not hearing aids are going to help them. You can sit them in the sound field and do a very quick unaided versus aided speech-in-noise test.  The results can give them the confidence that yes, hearing aids really do work and, in fact, they just did better in background noise during this testing, which is the very problem that they reported when they came in. In this case, you should use a relatively soft input level to demonstrate the benefits of audibility. If you use a louder presentation level, and they have only a mild-to-moderate hearing loss, there may not be any difference, aided or unaided.

And a bonus reason: MarkeTrak VIII revealed that when you do speech testing as part of the hearing aid fitting, patient satisfaction and patient loyalty improve. We are not really sure why, as that wasn't specifically asked as part of the survey. It could simply be that the act of doing speech testing gives the patient confidence that the hearing aids are working.  Or, knowing the patient’s speech understanding in background prompted the dispensing audiologist to be a better counselor.

For more information, check out the course Signia Expert Series: Speech-in-Noise Testing for Selection and Fitting of Hearing Aids: Worth the Effort?  This course discusses the rationale for speech-in-noise testing, reviews common tests and their clinical uses, and includes many case studies with real-world application.


h gustav mueller

H. Gustav Mueller, PhD

Dr. H. Gustav Mueller holds faculty positions with Vanderbilt University, the University of Northern Colorado and Rush University. He is a consultant for WSAudiology and Contributing Editor for AudiologyOnline, where he has the monthly column “20Q With Gus.”  Dr. Mueller is a Founder of the American Academy of Audiology and a Fellow of the American Speech and Hearing Association.  He has co-authored over ten books on hearing aids and hearing aid fitting, including the recent three-volume Modern Hearing Aids series, and the clinical text on Speech Mapping and Probe Microphone Measures. Gus is the co-founder of the popular website www.earTunes.com, and resides on a tropic North Dakota island, just outside the city of Bismarck


Related Courses

Signia Expert Series: Hearing Aid Fitting Nuggets Mined From Recent Research
Presented by H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Signia

Presenter

H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Course: #37894Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Information presented in a clear way with immediately relatable and recognizable clinical situations'   Read Reviews
Each year, over 300 articles are published in professional journals related to the function and fitting of hearing aids. Some are rather esoteric, but others have data that provide unique fitting tips that can be applied on Monday morning! We'll review the key findings of some of this emerging research that hopefully will be useful to you and beneficial for your patients.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Signia Expert Series: Is autoREMfit a Reasonable Verification Alternative?
Presented by H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Signia

Presenter

H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Course: #32808Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'speaker, content'   Read Reviews
Today, most all major hearing aid manufacturers have partnered with one or more probe-mic companies to facilitate autoREMfit. That is, the interaction between the fitting software and the real-ear measures allow for automatically fitting to prescriptive targets. The notion is that this approach is faster than traditional verification, speeding up the fitting process. But is the procedure valid? Is it reliable? Is it as good as "clinician fit"? That's what we'll talk about in this webinar.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

What's Trending in the World of Amplification?
Presented by Catherine Palmer, PhD, Pamela Souza, PhD, Thomas Powers, PhD, H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Signia

Presenters

Catherine Palmer, PhDPamela Souza, PhDThomas Powers, PhDH. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Course: #31846Level: Intermediate4 Hours
  'Better understanding of the future of OTC'   Read Reviews
Transition is happening all around us. In our professional world, these changes can relate to patient care, research findings and how the industry is changing. Learn how to adapt your clinical skills to meet the needs of patients as their world changes and our profession changes.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Signia Expert Series: Ten (or More) Common Misconceptions Related to Fitting Hearing Aids
Presented by H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Signia

Presenter

H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Course: #36750Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Will start using NAL-NL2 instead of manufacturers' proprietary'   Read Reviews
In the everyday practice of fitting hearing aids, we develop many beliefs, about both the technology and the fitting procedures. Some of these beliefs are based on things we think we have read, things we have heard from a rep, things from our fitting experiences, or things we just believe to be true because we always have. But for most of us, not all of them really are true. This presentation will reveal some of the most common misconceptions related to the fitting and operation of hearing aids.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Signia Podcast Series: Hearing Aids and Quality of Life - Advantages of Features
Presented by H. Gustav Mueller, PhD, Brian Taylor, AuD
Audio
Signia

Presenters

H. Gustav Mueller, PhDBrian Taylor, AuD
Course: #35990Level: Intermediate0.5 Hours
  'Easy listening and interesting!'   Read Reviews
This course will review how the use of hearing aids can impact the user’s quality of life in the areas of soundscape awareness, stress reduction, physical activity, communication, socialization and mental alertness. We will specifically look at different hearing features, and review research regarding how these features can alter benefit.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More