Question
I gave a young man (age 7y 11 mo) the SSW the other day and he had an interesting response pattern that I hadn't seen before. He would get the LC word incorrect but replace it with the RNC word, e.g. meat sauce meat ball, house fly house work, black board black mail, school bell church bell, ice cream sweet cream etc. He did this nine times. He also had three back-to-back qualifiers. Results were TFM and DEC. Order high/low was abnormal. PS was normal right on the border of normal (17). He could not do the Pitch Pattern Sequence Test. Speech-in-noise results were within normal limits for his age. Three separate individuals filled out an auditory concerns checklist independent of one another, and all three were nearly identical. * problems with phonics * frequently asks for repetition * has difficulty with reading recognition, spelling and writing * demonstrates good reading comprehension but has poor spelling and writing skills. Anyway, I am wondering if anyone else has run into this pattern and if it has any particular implication or significance?
Answer
The response you noted is referred to as the "available word". To explain: The SSW items were designed so that every item represented 3 spondees. For example, "meat sauce base ball" are the 2 obvious spondees, but in addition, "meat ball" that is formed if you drop out the 2 competing words. When people do not know one of the competing words (LC or RC) they can pull the opposite non-competing word to make a spondee (just as your 7-year-old did). Had he missed the RC word he would have said "meat ball base ball". I am delighted that a person uses the available word because obviously this child had no idea what the LC word was (if he took 'meat' for 'base'). If he did not take the available word he might have guessed and gotten some of the 9 LC words correct. Likely the first time the youngster gave an available word he likely looked quizzically at the audiologist. When this happens to me I give them a 'thumbs-up' (if they guessed they might not make an error on the word they missed.
What does this pattern tell us? I don't know. I have always assumed that it was simply an attempt to make a reasonable spondee. You did a very nice job of pulling the information together (primarily DEC and TFM if there is no Type-A). This agrees with what the questionnaire suggests and thus gives you more assurance. If the child has had speech therapy or auditory training (including phonological awareness or intensive phonics) this would help to explain his passing score on PS. If you use the PS Qualifiers to get a Qualitative PS Score you increase your chances of picking up the kids who have had training but are not yet 'cured' of DEC.
Jack Katz has been involved with the study of APD for more than 40 years. He has served as clinician, researcher, writer and teacher of this subject. He has developed diagnostic tests and therapy procedures that are widely used in the US and elsewhere. Eighteen years ago he formulated and researched (with others) an APD category system that has become known as the 'Buffalo Model'. He retired from the University at Buffalo in 2002 and is now devoting much of his time to a private practice providing high quality diagnostic and therapeutic Auditory Processing services in the Kansas City area.
Jack Katz, PhD, CCC-A/SLP
Jack Katz has been involved in the study of central auditory disorders for over five decades. He has developed effective tests and therapy procedures to evaluate and remediate this prevalent problem. He has editied several books on this topic and has written many articles and chapters and has presented on this topic nationally and internationally. He has just completed a book focusing on therapy for APD that will be distributed by Educational Audiology Association. Dr. Katz has spent 50 years developing the SSW test as a measure of central auditory function.
Related Courses
1https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/interprofessional-practice-to-holistically-treat-38166Interprofessional Practice to Holistically Treat APD: An Evidenced-based ApproachThis course will focus on treatment of APD in context of interprofessional practice and holistic approach.. A review of previous methodology will first be reviewed, then will be followed by evidence of an interprofessional approach and why this is a preferred method. Concomittant diagnoses most closely associated with APD in military professions will be discussed.auditory, textual, visual
This course will focus on treatment of APD in context of interprofessional practice and holistic approach.. A review of previous methodology will first be reviewed, then will be followed by evidence of an interprofessional approach and why this is a preferred method. Concomittant diagnoses most closely associated with APD in military professions will be discussed.
2https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/20q-auditory-processing-disorders-there-3945420Q: Auditory Processing Disorders - Is There a Gold Standard?This course describes the origins and current views on the auditory processing disorder (APD) construct. This course includes a discussion of the identification of the “gold” or reference standard test (or test battery) used for the diagnosis of an APD.textual, visual
This course describes the origins and current views on the auditory processing disorder (APD) construct. This course includes a discussion of the identification of the “gold” or reference standard test (or test battery) used for the diagnosis of an APD.
3https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/using-amplification-to-address-functional-37924Using Amplification to Address Functional Hearing Loss and Auditory Processing DisordersThis presentation is designed to discuss the role of hearing aids/amplification in the treatment of functional hearing losses/auditory processing disorders.auditory, textual, visual
'The presenter was very knowledgeable about the subject area and presented the course information in a manner that was concise and easy to understand'Read Reviews
This presentation is designed to discuss the role of hearing aids/amplification in the treatment of functional hearing losses/auditory processing disorders.
4https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/auditory-processing-disorder-and-blast-31270Auditory Processing Disorder and Blast TraumaThis course will focus on the current approach to blast trauma and the role of the audiologist in working with this population. Characteristics, assessment tools, and treatment will be discussed.auditory, textual, visual
This course will focus on the current approach to blast trauma and the role of the audiologist in working with this population. Characteristics, assessment tools, and treatment will be discussed.
5https://www.audiologyonline.com/audiology-ceus/course/adding-capd-testing-to-audiology-38182Adding CAPD Testing to Audiology Clinical Services in DOD and VAThis course will guide clinicians in determining the necessary knowledge, test materials, documents, templates, and supervision/mentorship to add CAPD services to their clinic. Information will include guidelines, seminar articles, where to find normative data, and suggestions for test batteries.auditory, textual, visual
This course will guide clinicians in determining the necessary knowledge, test materials, documents, templates, and supervision/mentorship to add CAPD services to their clinic. Information will include guidelines, seminar articles, where to find normative data, and suggestions for test batteries.
