AudiologyOnline Phone: 800-753-2160
Otometrics Otoscan - March 2020

Sensitivity of SISI and ABLB in Identifying Site of Lesion

Don W. Worthington, PhD

August 18, 2008

Share:

Question

We recently had a new staff member join our department. He has worked for 16 years at one hospital, under the direction of ENT. Basically, if ENT asked for a test he performed it, no questions asked. He wants us to incorporate SISI and tone decay testing into our retrocochlear battery to differentiate cochlear from retrocochlear hearing losses. I have been practicing for 17 years and have never seen the SISI used nor have I used it myself. We talked about it in school, as well as ABLB, but never used either of them. I have always had access to ABR, reflex testing and reflex decay. I did use tone decay for many years, but never saw it successful in identifying any patients with retrocochlear pathology so discontinued using it. I am wondering what current best practice recommendations are with regard to use of either of these tests. We have ABR and OAE testing at our hospital as well as MRI. Is there any basis for using either of these two tests to assist in the diagnosis of a patient with retrocochlear pathology OR to differentiate sensory from neural hearing loss?

Answer

This is not a new question. Audiologists have been challenged with the task of identifying and quantifying hearing loss, and identifying the site of lesion (location) causing a hearing loss since we have been a profession. To this end, numerous tests have been devised, starting with the Alternate Binaural Loudness Balance (ABLB) in 1928. Over the past 80 years, over 40 audiological site of lesion tests (or modifications of other tests) have been reported in the literature. Many of these test procedures are still taught in graduate programs and many are still used clinically. Have these tests persisted over time because they are the best or because individuals have not looked critically at the effectiveness or efficiency of the various tests, particularly in differentiating between cochlear and retrocochlear lesions? Over the years, a number of investigators have addressed this issue. In 1988 there was a book chapter "Clinical Audiology: Using the Test Battery," written by Don W. Worthington in a book called "International Perspectives On Communication Disorders," edited by Sanford E. Gerber and George Mencher, published by Gallaudet University Press. In that chapter, there is a discussion of a decision matrix model suggested by Dr. James Jerger for determining the sensitivity, specificity, predictive value, and efficiency for evaluating audiological tests and determining which tests should be utilized in the clinic. The chapter is a review not of every auditory site-of-lesion test, but rather of those tests that were in frequent clinical use at that time.

On the basis of the review by Worthington and at least 6 other investigators, a group of tests can be selected that are sensitive, specific, and efficient and require a minimum of time to administer. The recommended tests at that time were: auditory brainstem response (ABR), acoustic reflex/reflex decay, tone decay (Olsen-Noffsinger modification), and high-level speech discrimination (PI-PB modification). Clearly, several of the tests that were used at that time in site-of-lesion batteries were neither sensitive nor efficient in the detection of retrocochlear pathology. These were ABLB, Bekesy, and SISI.

One should take the time to review the specific test battery that is used in their clinic, remembering that the goal is to be effective, efficient and cost effective in identifying or localizing a deficit in the auditory system. Also keep in mind, the tests we perform are tests of function and cannot determine the specific pathology. Be sure that you are as critical of new tests and the information that they provide as you determine your site-of-lesion-battery.

Dr. Don W. Worthington has been an audiologist for over 30 years. He is currently the Director of the Intermountain Hearing & Balance Center which is located in Salt Lake City, Utah. He loves the field of Audiology.


Don W. Worthington, PhD

Director of the IHC Hearing and Balance Center

Dr. Don W. Worthington received his B.S. and his M.S. from Utah State University and his Ph.D. from Northwestern University. His initial work in audiology was in private practice. He later served as an audiologist in the United States Army where he was stationed at Walter Reed General Hospital. He served as the first non medical Director of the Army Audiology and Speech Center, and as Audiology Consultant to the Army Surgeon General. During his time in the Army he helped increase the number of Audiology positions from 6 to 63. He went to Boys Town National Research Hospital in 1975 as Director of Audiology and Speech Pathology. Dr. Worthington has served as, President of the American Auditory Society, a Panel member and Consultant for the Ear Nose and Throat Devices Panel of the Food and Drug Administration, Consultant to the Veteran Administration Hearing Aid Program, a member of the Board of Representatives of the American Academy of Audiology, a Legislative Counselor to the American Speech Language Hearing Association, and on numerous other committees both within the state and nationally. He has made numerous presentations in the areas of pediatric audiology, site of lesion evaluation, auditory evoked potentials and vestibular evaluation and treatment.. In 1993 He moved to Salt Lake City where he has built a nationally recognized Center for Hearing and Balance Disorders. He has been author and co author of a number of publications. He is currently Director of the IHC Hearing and Balance Center, in Salt Lake City, Utah. He has been the recipient of a number of honors and awards.


Related Courses

Common Errors in Diagnostic Audiology: Tips for Improving Efficiency, Accuracy and Outcomes
Presented by James W. Hall III, PhD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenter

James W. Hall III, PhD
Course: #30162Level: Advanced3 Hours
  'Thanks Prof'   Read Reviews
This practical 3-part course series reviews standard diagnostic audiology procedures and the common errors that can lead to clinical inefficiency and inaccurate results. Easy to implement guidance is provided for cleaning up clinical protocols to ensure that audiological testing yields the highest quality information in a cost-efficient manner for an accurate diagnosis and improved patient outcomes.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Evoked Potentials Part 1: Good Practice and Auditory Brainstem Response
Presented by Kathleen Hill, AuD, FAAA
Recorded Webinar
Natus (formerly Otometrics)

Presenter

Kathleen Hill, AuD, FAAA
Course: #31210Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Good review of the basics'   Read Reviews
This course describes Auditory Brainstem Response testing. Test parameters, waveform identification and diagnostic techniques are reviewed.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

A Guide to Bithermal Caloric Testing
Presented by Amanda Cerka Mroz, AuD, FAAA, CCC-A
Recorded Webinar
Natus (formerly Otometrics)

Presenter

Amanda Cerka Mroz, AuD, FAAA, CCC-A
Course: #815Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'very concise'   Read Reviews
No CEUs/Hours Offered
The purpose of this course is to provide an in-depth discussion of the caloric testing portion of the VNG/ENG test battery. Content will include descriptions of testing procedures, analysis and interpretation of results.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Before the Hearing Aid Fitting: What Pre-Tests Provide "Bang for the Buck"? (Part 1)
Presented by H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Signia

Presenter

H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Course: #849Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'Practical aspects of the topic'   Read Reviews
No CEUs/Hours Offered
This course provides a discussion of various pre-fitting measures that can provide valuable insight to the abilities, preferences and expectations of the wearer.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

How Loud is Too Loud? Using LDL Measures for Hearing Aid Fitting and Verification (Part 2)
Presented by H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Recorded Webinar
Signia

Presenter

H. Gustav Mueller, PhD
Course: #874Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'Content material, well organized'   Read Reviews
No CEUs/Hours Offered
The second installment in LDL measures overview including how these measures will affect the hearing aid fitting. NOTE: The two additional handouts for this course are currently unavailable.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More