AudiologyOnline Phone: 800-753-2160
Consult YHM Banner - December 2018

Carhart's Notch - New Research Findings

Diana C. Emanuel, PhD, CCC-A

June 8, 2009

Share:

Question

Why does the Carhart notch appear at 2000Hz in otosclerotic patients and at no other frequency?

Answer

An audiometric finding characteristic of otosclerosis is an increase in bone conduction (BC) threshold with a peak at 2,000 Hz known as Carhart's notch (Carhart, 1950). Although the notch occurs at 2,000 Hz, a reduction in bone conduction sensitivity is seen from 500 to 4,000 Hz which is, on average, 5 dB at 500 Hz, 10 dB at 1000 Hz, 15 dB at 2000 Hz, and 5 dB at 4,000 Hz (Carhart, 1971). Carhart attributed this phenomenon to "mechanical factors associated with stapedial fixation." The Carhart notch is not a true indication of "cochlear reserve" and this BC loss may be corrected by successful stapes surgery (Tonndorf, 1971). Carhart (1971) and Tonndorf (1971) provided a review of several theories to explain this phenomenon. Further, Tonndorf (1971) provided a summary of the results of his studies of stapes fixation in various mammals (cats, dogs, guinea pigs, rats, and humans). Tonndorf (1971) explained that the magnitude of the Carhart notch depended on the extent the middle ear contributed to the total BC response in each of the species tested. Further, he explained the frequency of the notch varied depending on the natural (resonance) frequency of the ossicular chain for BC signals.

It has been well established that the resonance frequency of the middle ear for air conducted (AC) stimulation is around 800-1200 Hz (e.g., Margolis et al., 1985). So why is the Carhart notch seen at 2,000 Hz? The answer is because the primary resonance of the ossicular chain for BC signals differs from the primary resonance of the chain for AC signals and is about 1600-1700 Hz (Zwislocki, 1957). Thus, for any BC disorder that decreases the mobility of the ossicular chain, the 1600-1700 Hz frequency range is affected most prominently. The reason that the Carhart notch is seen audiometrically at 2000 Hz is because 2000 Hz is the closest frequency tested in a typical hearing threshold measurement.

Recently Homma and colleagues (2009) published a fascinating study on ossicular chain resonance based on the differences in response to AC and BC stimulation of five human temporal bones. Their research offers additional clarity on the issue of vibration modes of the middle ear. According to their data, the ossicular chain has two basic modes of vibration. The first mode, with a peak around 1200 Hz, is the primary mode for AC stimulation. This mode is associated with a "hinging" motion of the ossicles caused by AC stimulation of the tympanic membrane at the umbo. The second mode, with a peak around 1700 Hz, is described as a "pivoting" motion of the malleus/incus, with an axis of rotation somewhat orthogonal to the axis of rotation associated with the "hinging" motion. The second mode is less robust than the primary mode for AC stimulation, but it is the dominant mode when excited by BC stimulation. A decreased mobility of the ossicular chain at 1700 Hz due to otosclerosis also affects the surrounding frequencies, but is seen most prominently as a BC loss at 2000 Hz in audiometric testing.

References

Carhart, R. (1950). Clinical application of bone conduction audiometry. Archives of Otolaryngology, 51, 798-808.

Carhart, R. (1971). Effects of stapes fixation on bone-conduction response. In I.M. Ventry, J.B. Chailkin, & R.F. Dixon (Eds.), Hearing measurement: A book of readings (pp. 116-129). New York, NY: Appleton-Century-Crofts.

Homma, K., Du, Y., Shizmu, Y., & Puria, S. (2009). Ossicular resonance modes of the human middle ear for bone and air conduction. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 125, 968-979.

Margolis, R. H., Van Camp, J., Wilson, R.H., & Creten, W.L. (1985). Multifrequency tympanometry in normal ears. Audiology, 24, 44-53.

Tonndorf, J. (1971). Animal experiments in bone conduction: Clinical conclusions. In I.M. Ventry, J.B. Chaiklin, & R.F. Dixon (Eds.), Hearing measurement: A book of readings (pp. 130-141). New York, NY: Appleton-Century-Crofts.

Dr. Diana Emanuel is a professor and the Audiology Graduate Program Director at Towson University. She can be reached at demanuel@towson.edu.

Dr. Emanuel would like to acknowledge the thoughtful criticism and suggestions of Dr. Tomasz Letowski on the original posting of this ATE in 2002;his suggestions led to this revised answer.


Diana C. Emanuel, PhD, CCC-A

professor and the program director for the Doctor of Audiology (Au.D.) program at Towson University

Diana C. Emanuel, Ph.D. is a professor and the program director for the Doctor of Audiology (Au.D.) program at Towson University. She earned her bachelor’s degree from Towson State University (1988) and her M.S. (1990) and Ph.D. (1993) from Penn State. She teaches in the areas of hearing science, audiology diagnostics, and anatomy and physiology of the auditory system. Her research interests include behavioral auditory processing assessment, hearing science, and pedagogy in Communication Sciences and Disorders. Dr. Emanuel is the co-author of Hearing Science (2009), which provides a student/instructor-friendly approach to learning and teaching hearing science.


Related Courses

Back to Basics: Pure Tone Testing and Audiogram Interpretation
Presented by L. Maureen Valente, PhD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenter

L. Maureen Valente, PhD
Course: #228381 Hour
  'Good review'   Read Reviews
No CEUs/Hours Offered
This presentation will describe best practices in pure-tone audiometry to ensure that results are valid. Further, the audience will learn important interpretation principles including determination of type, magnitude, configuration and symmetry of hearing loss.This course is recommended for students or for professionals returning to clinical work after an absence who would like a review of best practices in pure tone audiometry.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Review of Blast Injury, Its Effects on the Ear, and Assessing Patients Who are Veterans, Presented in Partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence Supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense
Presented by David Chandler, PhD, Mark Packer, MD, Kyle Dennis, PhD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenters

David Chandler, PhDMark Packer, MDKyle Dennis, PhD
Course: #238341 Hour
  'This course is very interesting'   Read Reviews
This webinar is part of a series of webinars on AudiologyOnline in June 2014 entitled, Auditory Assessment of the Blast-exposed Patient, presented in partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense. This webinar will provide a review of blast injury, a discussion of the anatomical and physiological effects of blast on the ear, and cover considerations for assessing patients who are veterans.

Please note: You may earn ABA Tier 1 credits for this course if you complete it as part of course 24668, "Auditory Assessment of the Blast-exposed Patient; Presented in Partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense.” Course 24668 contains recordings of the four events from this virtual conference on the topic of Blast Exposure. ABA Tier 1 CEUs can be earned only when all modules are completed as part of course 24668.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Comprehensive Management of the Blast-Exposed Patient Including Mental Health Implications, presented in partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense
Presented by Alison Cernich, PhD, Stephen C. Hunt, MD, MPH, Lucille Burgo-Black, MD, Robin Hurley, MD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenters

Alison Cernich, PhDStephen C. Hunt, MD, MPHLucille Burgo-Black, MDRobin Hurley, MD
Course: #238351 Hour
  'material and presenter'   Read Reviews
This webinar is part of a series of webinars on AudiologyOnline in June 2014 entitled, Auditory Assessment of the Blast-exposed Patient, presented in partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense. This webinar will discuss comprehensive management of the blast-exposed patient, including mental health implications. The other webinars in the series can be found in the AudiologyOnline course library, under the topic "Blast Exposure".

Please note: You may earn ABA Tier 1 credits for this course if you complete it as part of course 24668, "Auditory Assessment of the Blast-exposed Patient; Presented in Partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense.” Course 24668 contains recordings of the four events from this virtual conference on the topic of Blast Exposure. ABA Tier 1 CEUs can be earned only when all modules are completed as part of course 24668.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Audiological Intake Process, Auditory Assessment and Vestibular Assessment of the Blast-Exposed Patient, presented in partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense
Presented by Rachel McArdle, PhD, Karen Lambert, PT, DPT, NCS, Robin Pinto, AuD, Scott Forbes, AuD, Holly Burrows, AuD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenters

Rachel McArdle, PhDKaren Lambert, PT, DPT, NCSRobin Pinto, AuDScott Forbes, AuDHolly Burrows, AuD
Course: #238371 Hour
  'the material and presenters'   Read Reviews
This webinar is part of a series of webinars on AudiologyOnline in June 2014 entitled, Auditory Assessment of the Blast-exposed Patient, presented in partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense. This webinar will cover the audiological intake process, auditory assessment, and vestibular assessment for the blast-exposed patient. To register for the other webinars in this series, please visit the AudiologyOnline course library, and select "Blast Exposure" from the list of topics.

Please note: You may earn ABA Tier 1 credits for this course if you complete it as part of course 24668, "Auditory Assessment of the Blast-exposed Patient; Presented in Partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense.” Course 24668 contains recordings of the four events from this virtual conference on the topic of Blast Exposure. ABA Tier 1 CEUs can be earned only when all modules are completed as part of course 24668.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More

Central Auditory System Implications for the Blast-exposed Patient, presented in partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense
Presented by Jacquelyn Jackson, AuD, Linda Picon, MCD, CCC-SLP, Lina Kubli, PhD
Recorded Webinar
AudiologyOnline

Presenters

Jacquelyn Jackson, AuDLinda Picon, MCD, CCC-SLPLina Kubli, PhD
Course: #238381 Hour
  'The explanation of tests now used to assess this type of auditory processing disorder'   Read Reviews
This webinar is part of a series of webinars on AudiologyOnline in June 2014 entitled, Auditory Assessment of the Blast-exposed Patient, presented in partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense. This webinar will include discussion regarding the evaluation of auditory processing difficulties in patients who have been exposed to blasts. A brief description of audiological management strategies for auditory processing difficulties will also be discussed. To register for other courses in this series, please visit the AudiologyOnline course library, and select "Blast Exposure" from the topic list.

Please note: You may earn ABA Tier 1 credits for this course if you complete it as part of course 24668, "Auditory Assessment of the Blast-exposed Patient; Presented in Partnership with the Defense Hearing Center of Excellence supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense.” Course 24668 contains recordings of the four events from this virtual conference on the topic of Blast Exposure. ABA Tier 1 CEUs can be earned only when all modules are completed as part of course 24668.

View this Course for FREE.
Need CEUs? Become a AudiologyOnline member to get unlimited CEUs.

Only $99/yr

Learn More